KFC to appeal court judgment over salmonella poisoning

  • April 23, 2012
  • Matt Paish

KFC Australia has confirmed it will appeal a judgment in the NSW Supreme Court which found it to be responsible for causing the salmonella poisoning of a young girl in Sydney in 2005.

The family of Monika Samaan had sought compensation from KFC claiming Monika had become ill after eating a chicken Twister purchased from one of its Sydney stores in October 2005.

Monika suffered organ system failures and injuries, septic shock, severe brain injury and spastic quadriplegia. These injuries mean that Monika is now physically and intellectually disabled and is unable to function independently.

Following a four week trial in the NSW Supreme Court in 2010, Justice Rothman has now found in favour of the Samaan family.

In the case notes, Justice Rothman is stated as concluding, “The lack of documentary evidence in relation to any relevant complaints adds some weight to the defence, however, the real issues lie with the evidence of KFCs employees in relation to whether there is some possibility that the Twister Mr Samaan purchased for Monika could have become contaminated through errant food handling procedures between the time Crispy Strips had been cooked and the time the finished product was handed to Mr Samaan.

“The evidence of mishandling of the chicken provides enough weight, when combined with all of the other evidence, to enable the conclusion to be drawn that it is more likely than not Monika’s Twister became contaminated while it was being handled or made up.”

KFC to appeal judge’s decision

At issue is whether Mr Samaan did in fact purchase the Twister from the KFC and if so, whether the Twister caused the Salmonella poisoning that led to the Ms Samaan’s injuries.

KFC Australia’s Chief Corporate Affairs Officer Sally Glover said, “This is clearly a very tragic case but we are deeply disappointed and surprised by the judge’s decision.

“We believe the evidence showed KFC did not cause this tragedy and, after reviewing the judgment and seeking further advice from our lawyers, we have decided to appeal Justice Rothman’s decision.

“We feel deeply for Monika and the Samaan family however we also have a responsibility to defend KFC’s reputation as a provider of safe, high quality food.

“In fifty years in Australia, KFC has earned a reputation for having the highest food safety standards and we will continue working to ensure that record is maintained,” Ms Glover said.


Reader Comments

Australian Food News reserves the right to edit or not publish comments of a potentially offensive or defamatory nature. Comments will not be published if name and email address has not been provided (name and email will be withheld if requested).

The opinions expressed below are those of Australian Food News readers and do not necessarily reflect those of Australian Food News.

3 Responses to “KFC to appeal court judgment over salmonella poisoning”

  1. Linda Smith on April 28th, 2012 6:43 am

    It is a matter of who cashed the check. If KFC purchased that chicken from a food supplier, that supplier is responsible to KFC. KFC’s rememdy is to sue the faulty supplier the supplier can get remedy from the food processor. However, the girl’s family purchased the meal from KFC and thereby they are responsible to the family. As I just stated KFC can find remedy from the faulty suppler and if the supplier is not the food processor,they can get remedy through the food processor who sold to them. whomever you buy something from is directly responsible to you. The seller and the purchaser have a direct contract by bill and receipt of sale .

  2. ROB BUCKLEY on April 29th, 2012 8:19 pm

    What? All four people ate one twister, and the plaintiff got a different salmonella strain ? Unfortunately, judgements like this will cause a flood of litigation cases.

  3. Avoid the Food Safety ‘Danger Zone’ Maintaining Optimum Temperatures in Food Storage & Handling | Testo Australia on July 18th, 2013 5:14 pm

    […] [7] Aus Food News, “KFC to appeal court judgement over salmonella poisoning” 23 April 2012,http://www.ausfoodnews.com.au/2012/04/23/kfc-to-appeal-court-judgment-over-salmonella-poisoning.html […]

You must be logged in to post a comment.