GM soy linked to birth defects, cancer: new study

  • October 6, 2010
  • Josette Dunn

Monsanto’s herbicide Roundup used on genetically manipulated (GM) Roundup Ready crops is linked to human cell death, birth defects, cancer and miscarriages, says a report released at the European Parliament by an international group of scientists.

The report comes at a crucial time for Australia, where a popular infant soy formula has tested positive to unlabelled GM soy and corn, and Roundup Ready canola and cotton are grown.


The report, “GM Soy: Sustainable? Responsible?”, highlights new research by Argentine government scientist Professor Andrés Carrasco and an international coalition of scientists. They found serious health impacts from Roundup’s active ingredient, glyphosate, other chemicals in the formulated herbicide and its breakdown products. The report also provides a global overview of scientific papers and other documents on the impacts of GM soy production. The new research is published in the American Chemical Society journal ‘Chemical Research in Toxicology’.

GM Roundup Ready (RR) soy is now more than 90% of soy grown in North American and Argentina, and is also widely spread in Brazil, Paraguay, Uruguay and Bolivia. Monsanto’s own data shows Roundup herbicide sales have skyrocketed since GM RR crops were first planted in the USA in 1996[i]. The amount of toxic herbicide now used on soy has public health implications.

At the European Parliament in Brussels where the report was presented[ii], Prof Carrasco said childhood cancer had increased by 300% and babies with birth defects by 400% during the past decade in parts of Argentina. GM RR soy is grown there to supply European and Australian farmers with cheap GM animal feed: “I suspect the toxicity classification of glyphosate is too low… in some cases this can be a powerful poison,” he said.

The report also refers to studies that found: the uterus and ovaries of female rats fed GM RR soy showed changes; rabbits’ kidney and heart enzyme functions were disturbed. An intergenerational study of hamsters fed GM soy found slower growth rates and higher mortality among pups, and widespread infertility in the third generation[iii].

Bob Phelps, Executive Director of GM-free Australian advocacy group Gene Ethics, says the Australian response to genetically manipulated ingredients in baby formula is grossly inadequate. “Every test for GM contamination of S-26 formula has been positive for GM contamination. Yet our food regulator FSANZ refuses to mandate a recall, while Coles and Woolworths refuse to remove S-26 from their shelves.

“This routine contamination requires GM labelling under the law. If FSANZ won’t act on this false and misleading failure to label GM ingredients, then the ACCC should intervene,” he says.

“The Gillard Government must support independent Senator Nick Xenophon and Greens Senator Rachel Siewert who both want to fix up our food labelling laws. Labels must enable parents to choose baby formulas that that are not GM polluted. We call for the Government to ensure the assessment criteria of all novel foods, including GM, are amended and to remove the loopholes in Standard 1.5 that exempt most GM and other novel food products from any requirement to be labelled as such,” he concludes.


Reader Comments

Australian Food News reserves the right to edit or not publish comments of a potentially offensive or defamatory nature. Comments will not be published if name and email address has not been provided (name and email will be withheld if requested).

The opinions expressed below are those of Australian Food News readers and do not necessarily reflect those of Australian Food News.

2 Responses to “GM soy linked to birth defects, cancer: new study”

  1. Jochen Koester on October 6th, 2010 9:07 pm

    Congratulations to AFN for bringing this information to its readers in the Australian food industry!
    It seems that only hard core information like this will ring the right bells. Observing the recent approval for GM canola in parts of the country from Europe was a bit difficult to believe. The U.S. agricultural industry is facing huge problems with Roundup Ready crops and even admits it – and nobody in the Australian industry (nor in politics) seems to care. Perhaps it takes one of the most senior scientists from the world’s leading country in Roundup Ready penetration, Argentina, to place a wake-up call.
    Just read the Summary of the paper at and the link from Argentine babies to Australian babies will become evident.
    Agriculture, commodity traders as well as food and retail should not forget their final clientel!
    With kind regards.

  2. marion davis on October 9th, 2010 10:50 am

    sends shivers all over me. before choosing a certified organic infant formula for my babies i read the greenpeace gm shopping guide, way back in 2005 and knew that S26 was one of MANY to avoid. AND IT’S STILL ON THE SHELVES 5 YRS LATER!!! FSANZ have a lot to answer for. pity they are not working to protect us, the consumers, as they are supposed to, and protecting big business interests instead. disgusting!

You must be logged in to post a comment.